Review form
- Please return the completed form in text format to the Editor.
(If needed, use latex notation for mathematical symbols.)

Author(s): ...
Title: ...

Evaluation categories:
(A: Excellent; B: Good; C: Average; D: Poor; E: Very poor)

1 Content:

Overall evaluation (A-E):
Presentation and clarity (A-E):
Originality (A-E):
Does the paper meet the quality required for the journal Symmetry: Culture and Science? (A-E):
Significance of the topic from the aspect of symmetry in accordance with the aims and scope of S:C&S (A-E):
Application of the used methods, theory, examples, etc.(A-E):
Are the title, abstract and keywords appropriate? (Yes – No):
Are the figures and tables appropriate? (Yes – No):

2 Format

Does the formatting of the paper correspond to the template required for the journal? (Yes – No)
Content of the References (A-E):
Format of the References (A-E):

3 Language

English language (A-E):
Its English is acceptable as it is (Yes – No):
Its English needs to be checked and corrected by the author (Yes – No):
Its English needs minor correction, (spell-check is enough) (Yes – No):
In the latter case, list your recommendations to correct the English of the paper:

4 Final recommendation (select one):

- Acceptable for publication, as it is, or with minor changes
- Acceptable for publication with major changes
- Not acceptable for publication, but could be resubmitted
- Not acceptable for publication, and should not be resubmitted

5 Detailed comments:
please, put here your evaluation remarks (in particular with reasons if you propose to reject the submission), 
and list the recommended changes, if any:

6 Confidential comments to the editor (not communicated to the author(s)):